Why your heat pump bill jumps in a New York winter

Say what's going on with your heat pump, and a pro who works on them reaches out.

Get matched

Why did my heat pump bill jump this winter?

You pulled up your electric bill and the number from last month doesn't look right. Your heat pump has been running more than usual, and in New York, where power costs more than almost anywhere else in the country, that shows up fast. You're not imagining it. Something changed, either outside your house or inside the unit, and it's worth knowing which before you assume it's just the cold.

Cold air makes your heat pump work harder to pull in heat

A heat pump moves heat from outside air into your house, and the colder that air gets, the less heat there is to move and the longer the unit has to run to keep up. Below freezing, most heat pumps lean on backup electric resistance heat to make up the difference, and that backup heat uses far more power than the heat pump alone. If your unit is cycling on that backup strip heat often, through a hard New York winter, that alone can account for a bill that's climbed past what you paid to cool the house in July or August. A unit that's low on refrigerant or has a failing part will lean on that backup heat even more than it should.

A gray outdoor air conditioner condenser unit on a concrete pad beside a house with horizontal siding and an electrical disconnect box, surrounded by grass.

Why cold air works the unit harder

A heat pump moves heat from outside air into your home. When it's 20 degrees out, there's a lot less heat out there to grab, so the system has to run longer to pull the same warmth in. Below freezing, most units lean on backup electric resistance heat strips to keep up, and those draw power straight off the grid with none of the efficiency a heat pump normally has. That's the jump you're seeing. It isn't the equipment failing. It's the equipment working against a much bigger temperature gap than it was in October.

A white outdoor heat pump unit on a concrete pad beside a house with horizontal lap siding, with a plain light wall and grass lawn to the left.

A thin coat of frost changes everything

Your outdoor unit frosts over in winter, and it's supposed to run a defrost cycle to clear it. If that cycle isn't working right, ice builds up on the coil and blocks airflow across it. The system then has to work harder to pull the same heat through, and the heat strips kick on more to cover the gap. A coil that's icing over for long stretches, or a unit that sounds like it's running constantly, is usually a sign something in that defrost cycle needs a look.

Running hard, or running wrong

Normal winter running cost

  • A heat pump pulling warmth from 25 or 30 degree air runs for long stretches, and that's expected, not a fault.
  • You'll see the number climb through the cold months and come back down in spring without anyone touching the unit.
  • Rooms stay even and the system cycles on its own schedule, just more often than it did in October.
  • Defrost cycles kick on now and then to clear the outdoor coil, then the system goes right back to heating.
  • The thermostat holds the temperature you set within a degree or two, even on the coldest nights.

Signs something's actually wrong

  • The unit runs constantly and still can't hold the temperature you set, even a few degrees below it.
  • You hear it short cycling, shutting off and restarting every few minutes instead of running a steady stretch.
  • Ice builds up on the outdoor unit and doesn't clear during the defrost cycle like it should.
  • One room stays noticeably colder than the rest no matter how long the system runs.
  • The bill jumped well past what the cold alone would explain, and it stayed up even on milder days.
  • A contractor who works on heat pumps all winter in New York can look at the unit and tell you which of these it is.
A gray-haired man in a dark sweater sits on a light gray sofa in a living room, looking toward a sunlit window with trees outside.
A gray-haired man in a dark blue sweater sits on a light gray sofa in a sunlit living room, looking off to the side, with a potted plant, shelving unit, and large glass doors behind him.
A bearded man with graying hair in a dark green sweater sits on a sofa in a living room, looking off to the side, with a sliding glass door and a dim kitchen doorway behind him.
A gray-haired man in a dark knit sweater sits on a light gray sofa in a living room, looking toward a sunlit window, with houseplants, a lamp, and framed art in the background.
A gray outdoor condenser unit of an air conditioner or heat pump sits on a concrete pad beside a house with horizontal lap siding, with a wall-mounted disconnect box and conduit above it, mulched beds, shrubs and grass nearby.

The right pro for this job

Your request stays with one local pro.

A local pro who knows heat pumps gets your details and gets in touch.

Get one local pro

It costs nothing to send, and you don't have to hire anyone.

A light gray outdoor heat pump unit mounted on a concrete pad beside a house with horizontal lap siding, with refrigerant lines and conduit running to a wall-mounted electrical box, gravel and a leafy shrub nearby.
A heat pump that's clean, clear of ice, and running on its own cycle is doing what it's supposed to in a New York winter, even on the coldest nights.
An outdoor air conditioner condenser unit on a concrete pad beside a house with horizontal siding, with conduit, cables and an electrical box on the wall and mulch beds at either side.
Grime on the coils and ice that doesn't melt between cycles make the unit work harder than it should, and that shows up on your bill.

How your heat pump actually works

  • The thermostat calls for heat, and a reversing valve switches the refrigerant flow so the outdoor coil absorbs heat instead of releasing it.
  • A compressor pressurizes that refrigerant, which raises its temperature enough to give up heat once it's pumped inside to the indoor coil.
  • Below about 35 degrees, frost builds on the outdoor coil, so the unit runs a defrost cycle that briefly reverses the process again to melt it off.
  • Many systems switch on electric resistance heat strips during defrost or on the coldest nights, and those draw far more power than the compressor alone.
  • A clogged outdoor coil or a low refrigerant charge makes the compressor run longer to move the same amount of heat, which shows up as extra time on the meter.
  • The indoor air handler's fan runs continuously through each cycle, and a dirty blower wheel or a failing motor forces it to work harder to push the same air.

A heat pump doesn't make heat. It moves it. Even in cold outdoor air, there's warmth to grab, and the reversing valve is what decides which coil does the grabbing. Call for heat, and the valve switches so the outdoor coil pulls warmth in instead of dumping it out. The compressor's job is to squeeze the refrigerant until it's hot enough to release that heat once it reaches the indoor coil. That's the whole cycle, running over and over through the night.

Cold changes the math. Once outdoor temperatures drop toward the mid-30s, moisture in the air starts freezing onto the outdoor coil, the same way frost builds on a windshield. The system has to stop and run a defrost cycle to clear it, which means briefly reversing the flow again and sending heat outside to melt the ice. During that defrost, or on the coldest nights, many systems bring on electric heat strips to cover the gap. Those strips run on straight resistance heat, the same principle as a toaster, and they pull far more power than the compressor does on its own.

None of this is a malfunction. It's what the equipment is built to do. But a dirty outdoor coil, a low refrigerant charge, or a blower wheel caked with dust makes the compressor and fan work longer to move the same heat, and that extra run time is what shows up on the meter.

A weathered gray outdoor condenser unit sits on a concrete pad beside a house with horizontal siding, with refrigerant lines entering the wall at left and a mulched shrub bed at right.
Before you get your heat pump repair
A gray outdoor condenser unit on a concrete pad beside a house with horizontal lap siding, with an electrical disconnect box and insulated refrigerant lines on the wall, gravel in the foreground and a planting bed at left.
After you get your heat pump repair

If your heat pump is icing up, short cycling, or running nonstop and the house still feels a few degrees off, that's not normal winter behavior. Something is making it work harder than it should.

A unit that's losing a fight with the cold keeps pulling power without closing the gap, and the bill keeps climbing until the problem underneath it gets fixed.

A middle-aged woman with shoulder-length dark hair, wearing a gray cardigan over a cream top, sits in an upholstered armchair and looks toward a sunlit window, with a shelf holding framed pictures and a plant behind her.
A woman and a child wrapped together in a knitted gray blanket on a couch, with the child's head resting on her shoulder and a lit table lamp and houseplant in the background.

Running longer in the cold

A heat pump working harder as the temperature drops is doing its job. The bill goes up because the air outside has less heat to give, not because something's wrong.

Find a heat pump pro

Running longer because it's struggling

A heat pump fighting ice, short cycles, or a failing part pulls power without getting you the heat. That's a repair, not a cold snap.

Find a heat pump pro

Power costs 26.39 cents per kilowatt-hour statewide

At 26.39 cents per kilowatt-hour, every extra hour your heat pump runs this winter shows up fast on the bill. In most of the country that same hour costs a lot less, so the strain cold air puts on your system costs you more here than it would almost anywhere else.

EIA-861 2025 statewide residential average

A higher bill in January doesn't tell you which kind of running caused it. Cold air pulling more work out of your heat pump is normal. Ice that won't melt, a unit that won't stop, or a house that stays cold anyway is not. If what you're seeing matches the second one, it's worth having someone look before another month at 26.39 cents a kilowatt-hour goes by. A contractor who works on heat pumps in New York winters all season knows the difference between a system straining against the cold and one that's actually failing, and what usually causes each. When you request service through this page, you're matched with one licensed local contractor for your situation, not a list of companies competing for your call. You'll know where your system stands, and whether what you're paying for this winter is the cold doing its job on the unit, or the unit losing a fight it shouldn't be losing.

An outdoor heat pump unit with a large circular fan sits on a concrete pad beside a dark horizontal-sided building, with gravel ground and green shrubs at right.

A heat pump pro near you

The pro who reaches out is licensed in New York.

Step 1 of 3: Equipment