Set it once, to a steady temperature, and leave it there. A heat pump works best running at one setting all day and holding it, not cycling up and down the way a furnace does. In a New York winter, the outdoor coil already has to pull heat out of cold air, and every time you drop the thermostat back a few degrees to save money, you ask the unit to catch up later by running longer and harder, often with electric backup heat kicking in to help. That backup heat is what actually drives up your bill, since power here costs more than most of the country. Most homes here still heat with gas, so a heat pump is usually there to take the edge off shoulder season or pair with the furnace, not carry the whole winter alone. Setting it once and keeping filters and coils clean matters more to your bill than whatever number you pick.